Stoned-Campbell

  • Subscribe to our RSS feed.
  • Twitter
  • StumbleUpon
  • Reddit
  • Facebook
  • Digg

Wednesday, January 21, 2009

James A. Harding & the "Design" of Baptism

Posted on 8:36 AM by Unknown
I was recently asked this question during a discussion on baptism. This brother believed that unless one holds to a specific understanding of Acts 2.38 their obedience is not good enough. Here is the question: "But what about Acts 2:38 and its application/relevance today--if any? Again, baptism is what the original concern was about." I will here make an attempt to offer some insight from our Stoned-Campbell heritage on the matter ...

The question about baptism and its so called "design" has gone back and forth and I doubt it will ever be solved. According to my friend John Mark Hicks, between 1897 and 1907 there were right around TWO HUNDRED (that is 200) articles on rebaptism in the Gospel Advocate, Firm Foundation, Christian Leader & The Way, and the Octographic Review? That is a lot of ink! Many simply degenerated into rantings and name calling ... very unhelpful in any dialogue. But one article stands, in my view, above the rest for its clarity of thought, its civil tone and its tackling the issues head on.

That article comes from the pen of James A. Harding and he deals specifically with the question directed towards me. "HOU MUCH IS MEANT BY THE PHRASE, 'THE DESIGN OF BAPTISM?" was published in The Way in March 1900 covering pages 33 to 36. I will attempt to share the basic thrust of his article and supply relevant quotations from it.

Harding begins by reminding readers of The Way of his earlier article examining two theories concerning baptism 1) actual remission or a formal ceremonial cleansing. Now he will examine two more: 1) remission of sins is the design of baptism 2) remission is part of the design of baptism. Then Harding reminds his readers "the reader should remember that the text for these articles is Acts 2.38" (p. 33).

Harding then picks up the claim that "eis" denotes the design of baptism and this design is articulated in Acts 2.38. But then he lists 17x where "eis" follows the "words 'baptism,' 'baptize." These seventeen occurrences are: Mt 28.19; Ac 8.16; Ac 19.5; Rom 6.3(2x); Rom 6.4; Gal 3.27; Mk 1.4; Lk 3.3; Ac 2.38; 1 Cor 1.13; 1 Cor 1.15; Ac 19.3; 1 Cor 10.2; Mk 1.9; and 1 Cor 12.13. Harding comments on this list ...

"The idea of design is connected with, or suggested by, the word in every one of these places, it seems to me ..." (p. 34) Then he transitions to make these comments about Christian baptism.

"From these considerations it appears clear to me that to be baptized into the name of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit, into the name of the Lord Jesus, into Christ, into Christ Jesus, into death, are in effect one thing, inasmuch as to enter into one of these relationships is to enter into all of them. This was not always true, however, of baptism into remission of sins ... the inspired writers represent baptism as transferring one into thename, person, body, or death of Christ, or of the family of Christ, ten times; but only once do they represent us as being transferred into remission of sins. Is it not strange, then, that men will say remission of sins is the design..."

How did such a state of affairs come about, according to Harding? Why would preachers in the Churches of Christ make this argument then? Harding lays the blame upon the King James Version which he, and many others, had great reservations about Here are his own words on this point ...

"Moreover, in the one case (since Pentecost) in which he says we are baptized eis remission, the remission is not represented as the design of baptism, nor would any ever have supposed it was, I believe, had it not been for the incorrect translation of "eis" at this place; manifestly that which is
presented in this sentence as the object to be attained by being baptized is 'the gift of the Holy Spirit;' no one who is not utterly blinded by love for a false translation and a false interpretation can fail to see this when his attention is called to the truth.
"

Harding then quotes the Revised Version (1881) as the correct translation. He goes on to say "Peter did not say 'FOR [sic] the remission of sins.' The best scholarship of the world, in the best translations, has rejected 'for' as a rendering of 'eis' at this place." So what was the goal ... the end ... of being immersed in Acts 2.38?

"They were baptized unto (Greek 'into') the remission of their sins that they might receive the gift of the Holy Ghost."

Harding begins summarizing his inductive survey of baptism and eis by saying

"it is manifestly wrong to call remission of sins the design of baptism and insist that it shall be understood, or the baptism is of none effect, while no such requirement is made concerning the other passages where the same word ('eis') is used to show the relation or state into which the baptized is transferred."

But how would Harding handle one who comes from the "denominations" that has been immersed. Would he not ask him/her about the design of baptism. He says no!

"Because I doubt if there was ever a man who fully understood the design of the ordinance at the time of his baptism since Christ gave the commission. I am near fifty-two years of age; I have been a reader of the Bible, and have had my mind turned on this subject for the express purpose of studying it and getting ... yet I have not arrived ..."

What then is the biblical requirement for the candidate of baptism? What would Harding ask that Baptist or Methodist that had been immersed when they come to join a local congregation of the Churches of Christ?

"Did you believe with your whole heart that Jesus is the Christ, the Son of God, and did you confess him as Lord?"

If the person responded in the negative they would simply need to be baptized rather than rebaptized. But if they affirm positively then they are in fact a part of the family of God.

Harding's article is a good one. He has some very thoughtful and insightful words. Maybe there is spiritual wisdom in them. I believe there is ...
Email ThisBlogThis!Share to XShare to FacebookShare to Pinterest
Posted in Baptism, Church History, James A. Harding, Kingdom, Ministry, Mission, Preaching, Restoration History | No comments
Newer Post Older Post Home

0 comments:

Post a Comment

Subscribe to: Post Comments (Atom)

Popular Posts

  • What the "Assembly" is "About in the Psalms: Special Attention to Ps 95
    In Scripture a Spiritually minded worshiper comes to the assembly (i.e. gathering) of the People of God desiring five things: 1) The worshi...
  • Old Gospel Advocate Message Board Exchange (By Request): Crux Discussion
    Last night (Oct 27, 2010) I received an inquiry about a discussion that took place ages ago on the Old Gospel Advocate Message Board (in 200...
  • K. C. Moser: Student of the Word
    Alister McGrath in his recent outstanding study Christianity's Dangerous Idea asserts Protestantism gift to Christianity was the belief...
  • President Barack Obama
    Thoughts on President Barack Obama: A Historic Election Well it is, thankfully, finally over! We can all collectively exhale at least for a ...
  • Prayer in the Apocrypha 3: Judith's Psalm of Praise
    " Therefore this is a fine, good, holy, useful book, well worth reading by us Christians. For the words spoken by the persons in it s...
  • Barton W. Stone & the Debate Culture
    I grew up in a "debating culture" or perhaps it was a "sub-culture."  If the minister did not like what was going on a m...
  • So You're a Minister ... Leaves from a Journal Spanning 20 Years
    What does it mean to be a "minister?"  I believe this is a critical question for both congregations and those who are "minist...
  • The "Enjoyment" of Scripture
    Writing on the Ancestry of the King James Version has stimulated my mind in some fresh and new directions ... I grew up in a Bible believing...
  • Reflections on the Weekend
    What a holiday weekend! I have had Rachael and Talya all weekend long. We cooked Big Bird together (an 18lbs Turkey!!). We made home made ...
  • Bill Hybels & Bono 1
    If you are over the age of 50 the name "Bono" or "U2" may have no meaning to you at all. But I am fairly sure that those...

Categories

  • 1 Corinthians (3)
  • 1 Thessalonians (1)
  • 1 Timothy (1)
  • A Gathered People (3)
  • Abraham (1)
  • Acts (2)
  • Africa (1)
  • Alexander Campbell (23)
  • American Empire (1)
  • Amos (5)
  • Apocrypha (24)
  • Apologetics (1)
  • Baptism (10)
  • Barack Obama (1)
  • Barton W. Stone (3)
  • Benjamin Banneker (1)
  • Bible (107)
  • Black History (17)
  • Bobby's World (187)
  • Books (66)
  • C. S. Lewis (1)
  • Carl Ketherside (1)
  • Christian hope (57)
  • Christmas (14)
  • Christology (1)
  • Church (53)
  • Church History (84)
  • Clay Parkinson (1)
  • Colossians (7)
  • Contemporary Ethics (56)
  • Cool Stuff (2)
  • Culture (3)
  • Daniel (2)
  • David Lipscomb (6)
  • Deuteronomy (6)
  • Didache (1)
  • Discipleship (29)
  • Doug Doser (1)
  • Easter (3)
  • Ecclesiastes (3)
  • Environment (1)
  • Ephesians (4)
  • eschatology (25)
  • Esther (1)
  • Exegesis (149)
  • Exodus (2)
  • Faith (11)
  • Family (24)
  • Famiy (1)
  • Football (1)
  • Forgiveness (1)
  • Frederick Douglass (1)
  • Galileo (1)
  • Genesis (1)
  • Gnosticism (1)
  • Gordon Fee (1)
  • Gospel of John (1)
  • Gospel of Judas (1)
  • Grace (46)
  • Habakkuk (2)
  • Hanukkah (1)
  • Harriet Beecher Stowe (1)
  • Heaven (6)
  • Hebrew Bible (97)
  • Hebrews (2)
  • Hermeneutics (113)
  • Holding On (2)
  • Holy Kiss (1)
  • Holy Spirit (12)
  • Humor (7)
  • J. W. McGarvey (3)
  • J.N. Armstrong (1)
  • James (2)
  • James A. Harding (5)
  • James Challen (1)
  • Jeremiah (3)
  • Jerry Rushford (1)
  • Jesus (79)
  • Jewish Backgrounds (19)
  • John Lennon (1)
  • John Newton (1)
  • John Waddey (1)
  • John Wyclif (1)
  • Jonah (10)
  • Jonathan Edwards (2)
  • Journey (8)
  • Jude (1)
  • Judith (2)
  • K. C. Moser (6)
  • King David (1)
  • King James Version (23)
  • Kingdom (118)
  • Kingdom Come (4)
  • Lectures (10)
  • Lord's Supper (4)
  • Love (4)
  • Luke (2)
  • Mark (1)
  • Marriage (2)
  • Martin Luther (1)
  • Martin Luther King (3)
  • Matthew (1)
  • Milwaukee (6)
  • Ministry (175)
  • Mission (43)
  • Monroe Hawley (1)
  • Moses Lard (1)
  • Movies (1)
  • Music (62)
  • N.T. Wright (5)
  • Nahum (2)
  • New Mexico (1)
  • Numbers (1)
  • Pardee Butler (1)
  • Patternism (4)
  • Paul (2)
  • Personal (11)
  • Philippians (1)
  • Politics (4)
  • Prayer (46)
  • Preaching (152)
  • Psalms (15)
  • R. C. Bell (1)
  • R. H. Boll (1)
  • Race Relations (21)
  • Reading (2)
  • Restoration History (77)
  • resurrection (2)
  • Revelation (1)
  • Richard Oster (1)
  • Romans (3)
  • S. R. Cassius (1)
  • Sabbath (2)
  • Salvation (2)
  • Sectarianism (8)
  • Septuagint (1)
  • Sexuality (2)
  • Sirach (1)
  • Slavery (2)
  • Song of Songs (4)
  • Spiritual Disciplines (50)
  • Suffering (11)
  • Tags (7)
  • Theodicy (2)
  • Tobit (3)
  • Tucson (22)
  • Uncle Tom's Cabin (2)
  • Unity (35)
  • Veggie Tales (1)
  • Walter Scott (1)
  • War -Peace (8)
  • Wisdom of Solomon (2)
  • Women (7)
  • Worship (43)

Blog Archive

  • ►  2013 (23)
    • ►  August (8)
    • ►  July (2)
    • ►  June (5)
    • ►  May (2)
    • ►  March (1)
    • ►  February (3)
    • ►  January (2)
  • ►  2012 (33)
    • ►  December (4)
    • ►  November (4)
    • ►  October (1)
    • ►  August (2)
    • ►  July (1)
    • ►  June (4)
    • ►  May (3)
    • ►  April (1)
    • ►  March (4)
    • ►  February (4)
    • ►  January (5)
  • ►  2011 (58)
    • ►  December (7)
    • ►  November (1)
    • ►  October (3)
    • ►  September (4)
    • ►  August (9)
    • ►  July (6)
    • ►  June (7)
    • ►  May (6)
    • ►  April (5)
    • ►  March (4)
    • ►  January (6)
  • ►  2010 (49)
    • ►  December (4)
    • ►  November (2)
    • ►  October (6)
    • ►  September (1)
    • ►  August (8)
    • ►  July (7)
    • ►  June (1)
    • ►  May (7)
    • ►  April (2)
    • ►  March (5)
    • ►  February (4)
    • ►  January (2)
  • ▼  2009 (61)
    • ►  December (9)
    • ►  October (4)
    • ►  September (4)
    • ►  July (1)
    • ►  May (10)
    • ►  April (3)
    • ►  March (5)
    • ►  February (17)
    • ▼  January (8)
      • Todd Deaver, Facing Our Failure: Thoughts
      • James A. Harding & the "Design" of Baptism
      • A New Hallelujah - Michael W Smith
      • Stoned Links on the Importance of the Hebrew Bible
      • Here. There. Everywhere: Good Stuff on the Net
      • Beer & The Bible: What the Bible Really Says about It
      • When Wine is Really "Wine"
      • Dare We Be "Godly?"
  • ►  2008 (131)
    • ►  December (12)
    • ►  November (10)
    • ►  October (13)
    • ►  September (19)
    • ►  August (13)
    • ►  July (13)
    • ►  May (15)
    • ►  April (13)
    • ►  March (11)
    • ►  February (7)
    • ►  January (5)
  • ►  2007 (115)
    • ►  December (5)
    • ►  November (2)
    • ►  October (7)
    • ►  September (9)
    • ►  August (9)
    • ►  July (11)
    • ►  June (7)
    • ►  May (17)
    • ►  April (15)
    • ►  March (12)
    • ►  February (11)
    • ►  January (10)
  • ►  2006 (30)
    • ►  December (11)
    • ►  November (6)
    • ►  October (10)
    • ►  September (3)
Powered by Blogger.

About Me

Unknown
View my complete profile